Indiana University
Indiana University School of Journalism alumnus Andrew Prinsen, BAJ '07, is reporting from India as part of his Ross Hazeltine Traveling Scholarship, a $7,000 grant to report on global issues outside North America.
Andrew Prinsen | Sept. 4, 2007
The boy pulls himself along the train’s aisle on his hands, his good leg propelling him as his limp one drags behind, his bare feet sliding silently along the vinyl floor. He uses a small broom, stiff, bristly reeds lashed together, to poke under the seats, fetching a surprising amount of dirt and trash. Old ticket stubs and empty betel nut wrappers, plastered with a thin film of grease and dirt, are pulled from the locomotive’s crevices and added to the growing pile that is pushed along in front of his thin frame. And then I wonder if his leg really is limp or if his gesture, the humbling act of lowering himself to the floor, is simply a way of lowering his own status in the society of the train’s compartment, putting people more at ease and more willing to pay him a rupee since he is doing the job "his people were meant to do."

I lean my head back against my part of the bench seat right next to the bars in the window. You always hear trains approaching from the other direction about 10 seconds before they’re on you, their moaning whistles sounding so far away at first and then deafening as the column of air they have been pushing meets your face like a hot, ending slap. The force of both trains moving towards each other uncomfortably pops your ears and leaves you with a ringing like someone unloaded a 12 gauge right next to your head.

We depart the train in the early morning at a small, mostly lifeless station. I make my way over to the restroom which is "pay to use" as are most public facilities. The woman sitting outside collecting money holds out her hand before I enter and I fish a crumpled five rupee bill out of my pocket. She gives me back three rupee coins and I stand with my hand still out, waiting for one more. She looks down at my hand, then back up at my face before holding up one bony finger in question form. I nod my head, realizing she’s asking the American equivalent of "you’re going number one, then?" It’s odd for me, as I’m not much accustomed to explaining the plans for my restroom visits to old women, but this is normal here and she presses the remaining rupee into my palm, satisfied that I will not be using two rupees worth of toilet services.

And that’s the funny thing about India. I’ve heard before that it is a place of contradictions, and I’m finding that in some respects to be very true. It’s a place where marriages are arranged and if someone has an attraction or, heaven forbid, a boyfriend or girlfriend, it’s something you simply don’t speak of. There are no billboards or advertisements showing women wearing anything less than the standard sari. But it’s also a place where other basics of human nature that are more repressed in the West are laid brutally out in the open. It’s perfectly normal, for example, to be walking to dinner in the center of town and pass a few men on the way taking a leak on a wall.

The other night, I was sitting in a restaurant and there happened to be a scale sitting next to my table, the kind you might be used to seeing in dirty Chevron station bathrooms back home. But this one was right there in the middle of the place, between my table and another where a family of four was happily chomping on their dosa and curry. And then suddenly a woman in her late 20s had hopped onto the machine and plunked a coin into the slot before yelling the results to her husband across the room. I couldn’t imagine something like this happening at home and still don’t really know what to think about it.

Any time we’re in a larger city there will be people sprawled out on any free piece of concrete, filthy and exhausted beyond belief, at least they must be to sleep as soundly as they do with their limbs hanging out onto the blacktop, just inches from traffic. For me it all just seems so vivid or gritty, textured, real. And it’s not that we don’t have humanity like this where I come from. We do, but it gets hidden somehow. In India that humanity is accentuated. Here, the humanity is in your face.
This is an image made of the view from our hotel’s small balcony in Nagpur.
Two things in one here: an example of India’s sketchy bootleg electric wiring, and
also, if you look closely, you can see a man sleeping in a doorway
down below. Apparently the spot was available.
Back to Uncategorized

3 Responses to “The grit”

  1. Melissa F. -

    Tim – I’ve been following the blog and have really enjoyed keeping up with where you’re at and what you’re seeing. I am really proud of you and Andy. You are both in my prayers along with the people and the needs you’re encountering. Keep safe!

    Love
    Melissa F

  2. Louise Elpers -

    You are so correct in saying we “hide” what we don’t want to see. The thing is we “hide” our minds to what we don’t want to know. We “hide” our hearts to what we don’t want to feel. Thank your for pointing out the person sleeping in the doorway. It was easy to miss the person at first. As you “see” what is in front of you as your journey continues, I challenge you to realize the one you must look at in a new way is….yourself. In doing so, you will understand everything around you differently. A third world person urinates where he must because he has no toilet. The water that refreshes this person eventually returns to replenish the earth. It’s part of the circle of life. Thank you for all your sharing. I think you are an amazing young man! I wish you all the best!

  3. Pete B. -

    I wonder how vast and heterogenous India may be, i.e., that your trip so far is like someone seeing America by visiting the Midwest…do you suspect that if you were in Calcutta, Hyderabad. New Delhi or Mumbai (Bombay), you’d have the same experience? I remember your earlier blog entry where you repeat the “cognitive dissonance” you suggest here (”a place of contradictions”)…where do you think that’s from? Maybe because there’s so much more caste/class/economic differences, especially between “high” and “low,” than in the U.S.?
    Keep up the good reporting…be sure to take some “duff days” (no plans-just relaxing and fun) every so often!

Post a comment